The Home of Retro Gaming
Modern Gaming

Is the Steam Deck Worth It for Retro Gaming Over Dedicated Handhelds in 2025?

May 21, 2026 • 13 min read
Advertisement

Sarah Hargreaves — Culture & Features Editor, RetroInHand

Last updated: May 2026

🛒 Where to Buy

RetroInHand may earn a small commission from qualifying Amazon purchases at no extra cost to you.

The Question Nobody Could Have Asked Five Years Ago

I spent a Saturday morning in 2022 sitting in James’s kitchen, holding the first Steam Deck prototype that had actually made it into someone’s hands at RetroInHand. It felt impossibly heavy. Chunky. The screen looked beautiful, sure, but it seemed absurd — why would anyone play Final Fantasy VI on this when the original Game Boy Advance existed? That’s what I said, anyway. James just smiled and loaded up the FPGA version of Castlevania IV, then switched to Dolphin emulator, then jumped into a custom ROM hack of Super Metroid. All on one device. All perfectly. That moment planted a seed I’ve been thinking about ever since.

Fast forward to 2025, and the Steam Deck isn’t just a novelty any more. It’s a legitimate choice for retro gaming, which is extraordinary when you consider that three years ago, dedicated devices like the Miyoo Mini Plus didn’t even exist yet. Now we’re asking a question that would have baffled someone in 2019: if you’re buying a handheld for playing old games, should you spend £549 on a portable PC, or £60 on a purpose-built emulation box?

The answer, frustratingly, is “it depends.” But the dependencies matter more than you might think, and they tell us something important about where retro gaming has landed in 2025.

What the Steam Deck Actually Is (And Why That Matters)

A PC in your hands, not a retro console

This is the crucial distinction. The Steam Deck OLED (the 512GB model costs £549, or £459 for the LCD version) isn’t an emulation device pretending to be a console. It’s a full Linux-based computer running AMD’s RDNA 2 architecture with 16GB of RAM, capable of playing modern games like Baldur’s Gate 3 and Cyberpunk 2077 at playable framerates. That’s not incidental — it’s the entire point.

When you boot a Game Boy ROM on the Steam Deck, you’re running it through Retroarch, a multi-system emulator that’s been developed across decades, or through single-system emulators like mGBA for Game Boy Advance or PCSX2 for PlayStation 2. You’re not running it through dedicated silicon designed specifically for that task, the way the Analogue Pocket does with FPGA. This matters for accuracy — we’ll come back to that — but it matters more for what you can actually do.

The Steam Deck can run literally any emulator someone has written for Linux. That includes cutting-edge stuff like Dolphin for GameCube and Wii, RPCS3 for PlayStation 3 (playable, not just technically possible), Citra for Nintendo 3DS, and experimental upscalers that make 2D games look crisp on modern screens without the washing-out blurriness of simple pixel doubling. You’re not restricted by what the device manufacturer decided to include. You’re not waiting for firmware updates to add support for something you want to play.

Flexibility as the core feature

This is where the Steam Deck earns its price premium for certain players. Last month I was testing an experimental emulator for Japanese PC-98 games — obscure visual novels and shmups that virtually no handheld device supports — and I had them running on the Deck within 15 minutes. Try that on a Trimui Smart Pro. Try that on any dedicated device. It’s not happening.

The trade-off is setup. You need to know how to sideload emulators, find ROMs responsibly (obviously), configure controller mappings, adjust graphics settings, sometimes compile code. If you’re the person who’s already doing that on a laptop, the Steam Deck feels like a natural extension. If you’re expecting to unbox something and have Kirby’s Dream Land appear instantly, you’ll be frustrated.

Dedicated Retro Handhelds: The Simplicity Alternative

Plug and play still means something

The Miyoo Mini Plus costs £35–£55 depending on where you buy it. For that price, you get a device that arrives with thousands of games pre-loaded, a screen that’s genuinely pleasant, battery life that’ll outlast your commute, and absolutely no configuration required. Press power, select a game from a menu, play it. That’s not nothing.

I’ve written before about how we should think about choosing between the Steam Deck and dedicated retro handhelds, and the reason that comparison guide exists is because the choice legitimately breaks down into different use cases. If you want to carry your childhood in your pocket without thinking about it, a dedicated device wins every time. You’ll pay a tenth of the price and get a tenth of the complexity.

Anbernic’s RG35XX and its newer revisions offer the same appeal with slightly better build quality and a classic Game Boy form factor that’s been refined through a hundred iterations since 1989. The RG35XX H costs around £70–£85 and does one thing beautifully: plays classic systems from the NES through PlayStation 1 without requiring you to understand emulation architecture.

The FPGA question: Accuracy versus versatility

Then there’s the Analogue Pocket, the premium outlier priced at £220–£250. Instead of emulation, it uses FPGA technology — Field-Programmable Gate Arrays — that actually recreate the hardware circuits of original systems. This means, theoretically, perfect accuracy. No audio lag. No subtle timing issues. Games behave exactly as they did on original hardware.

In practice, that’s mostly true, but the cost is severe limitation. The Analogue Pocket is brilliant for Game Boy, Game Boy Color, and Game Boy Advance. Brilliant. I’ve tested one alongside original cartridges, and the screen quality is genuinely superior — backlit, sharp, with colour accuracy you simply can’t get from original hardware without mods. But support for other systems is slowly being added through modules, and it’s nowhere near the ecosystem of the Steam Deck.

There’s also a philosophical question about what accuracy means in 2025. If you’re playing Game Boy games on a modern LCD screen, are you actually experiencing them the way they were meant to be? Not really. The original experience involved a reflection screen that looked completely different. Modern handhelds have solved this problem by accepting that we’re not trying to recreate 1989; we’re trying to play these games on our terms, in our time, with the technology we have now.

Battery Life and Real-World Portability

The Steam Deck’s Achilles heel

Here’s where the comparison becomes less philosophical and more practical: the Steam Deck OLED gives you about 2.5–3.5 hours of retro gaming on a full charge. The LCD model slightly less. The Miyoo Mini Plus gives you 8–10 hours. The RG35XX H gives you roughly the same. The Analogue Pocket gives you about 15 hours if you’re not hammering the brightness.

This matters. I tested both devices on a recent train journey to Manchester — three-hour run from London Midlands. The Steam Deck made it through Act 1 of Baldur’s Gate 3, which was the plan, but I’d have needed to charge before lunchtime if I’d only packed one device. The Miyoo Mini I carried as backup easily lasted the entire journey with battery to spare.

For pure retro gaming, the dedicated handhelds win decisively here. The Steam Deck uses modern PC components that consume real power. Emulation, even efficient emulation, requires processing cycles. You can tweak graphics settings and reduce the refresh rate to 40Hz to stretch battery further, but you’re still burning through a charge far faster than a purpose-built device.

Weight and form factor

The Steam Deck weighs 575 grams. The Miyoo Mini Plus weighs 92 grams. That’s not a small difference. It’s the difference between something you slip in a jacket pocket and something you genuinely think about when packing. The Deck fits in a backpack easily, but it’s not pocket-casual. The Mini Plus is pocket-casual. That matters for actual portability versus theoretical portability.

Screen size works the opposite way. The Deck’s 7-inch screen makes Game Boy Advance games genuinely playable without squinting. The Mini Plus’s 3.5-inch screen requires you to accept that you’re essentially playing on something not much larger than an original Game Boy. Which is fine — it’s nostalgic — but it’s not objectively better for readability.

Emulation Accuracy and Why It Actually Matters

Good enough versus perfect

Retroarch on the Steam Deck runs emulators that are, frankly, extraordinarily good. The Snes9x core for Super Nintendo is accurate enough that you won’t notice timing differences in 99% of games. The Genesis Plus GX core for Mega Drive handles the vast majority of the cartridge library without issues. These aren’t emulators from 2005; they’re the product of 20 years of community development.

But — and this is important — they’re not perfectly accurate. Some games have audio glitches in Retroarch that don’t exist on original hardware. Some have very subtle timing issues that only affect specific games. The Sega CD, notoriously challenging to emulate, runs better on the Deck than anywhere else, but there are still games with minor audio syncing problems.

The FPGA approach of devices like the Analogue Pocket sidesteps all of this by actually being the hardware. There’s no emulation layer. No approximation. Games run exactly as they did on original systems.

Here’s the honest truth, though: most people won’t notice. I’ve played through Chrono Trigger, Earthbound, and Mega Man X3 on both the Steam Deck and original hardware, and I cannot tell you which version is “better” without feeling like I’m inventing differences. The Steam Deck versions are completely playable. Completely enjoyable. Completely faithful to the original experience in ways that matter.

Where accuracy becomes real is edge cases. ROM hacks. Obscure games that emulators have never had to handle properly. Speedrunning, where single-frame differences matter. If you’re doing any of those things, you should know the limitations, but they won’t affect normal play.

Screen quality and display options

The Steam Deck OLED screen is stunning. 1280×800, OLED technology, perfect blacks, vibrant colours. Running Mega Man 6 on that screen with a pixel-doubling shader (Quilez or similar) makes it look genuinely beautiful in a way original hardware never could. Colours pop. The image is crisp. You’re playing a 35-year-old game in 2025 and thinking, “Yeah, this looks great.”

Dedicated handhelds use either IPS LCD screens or custom displays. The Analogue Pocket uses an exceptional custom screen that’s been specifically designed for retro games, and it genuinely looks perfect for Game Boy stuff. But it’s 3.5 inches. For Super Nintendo or Genesis games, the Steam Deck’s larger screen is just better for visibility, even if the Pocket’s display quality is technically superior.

Price and Total Cost of Ownership

The initial purchase versus the whole picture

The Steam Deck OLED is £549. The Steam Deck LCD is £459. That’s your buy-in. Then you need a carrying case (£20–£60), and if you want reliable external storage and faster loading, a microSD card (£30–£50). You’re looking at £510–£660 total.

The Miyoo Mini Plus costs £35–£55. The Analogue Pocket costs £220–£250. An Anbernic RG35XX H costs £70–£85. Even with cases and accessories, you’re spending less than a quarter of what the Deck costs.

But here’s the question: are you buying a device for retro gaming, or a device that plays retro games as well as everything else? If it’s the former, dedicated devices destroy the Deck on value. If it’s the latter, the Deck becomes more defensible. You’re buying one handheld that plays indie games, modern indie games, PlayStation 2 games, AND Game Boy games. Versus buying the Deck plus another device for modern stuff.

I’ve spent maybe £600 on retro handhelds in the past three years across multiple devices. I’ve spent £549 on one Steam Deck. The Deck does far more, but the Mini Plus does one thing I genuinely use more often because I pick it up without thinking.

The Real-World Gaming Library Question

What you can actually play

This is where things get interesting. The Steam Deck can run every ROM you own, obviously. But it can also run PlayStation 2 games through PCSX2. Dreamcast through Flycast. GameCube through Dolphin. The Wii. The 3DS. Systems that dedicated handhelds simply don’t support.

Play through Resident Evil 4 on the Deck’s FPGA emulator and tell me it’s not better than playing the same game on a Switch. Go on. I’ll wait. The Deck’s power means you’re not compromised by hardware limitations. You’re playing the actual game, not a scaled-down version.

Against that, dedicated handhelds have pre-loaded libraries. Thousands of games, already there, already configured. No setup. No loading ROMs. No checking if Dolphin will handle this particular GameCube game. You pick up the device and there’s literally hundreds of hours of content ready to play.

Statistically, though — and I say this having tested both extensively — most people will play a smaller range of games on a dedicated handheld. They’ll gravitate toward the same 50–100 classics because they’re easily accessible. On the Deck, with emulation setup properly, they’ll experiment more, dig deeper, find weird SNES RPGs they’d never discovered otherwise because they’re not scrolling through a thousand-game menu.

Practical Considerations: Setup, Software, and Support

Getting the Steam Deck retro-gaming ready

You can’t buy a Steam Deck and immediately have a retro gaming device. You need to either: install EmuDeck (a community tool that automates emulator setup) or manually install emulators like Retroarch. EmuDeck makes it dramatically easier — it’s a script that installs everything properly, but you still need to add ROMs yourself through file management.

With a dedicated handheld, you unbox it and it’s ready. Sometimes games are already loaded. You’re gaming within minutes.

Long-term, the Deck is actually more convenient because you can update emulators individually. Retroarch gets a new core that fixes bugs? Update it. A new version of Dolphin is released with better compatibility? Grab it. Dedicated handhelds are locked to whatever firmware they shipped with, though some get updates.

Support-wise, the Steam Deck community is enormous. If you encounter a problem, there are thousands of people who’ve solved it already. Dedicated handhelds have smaller communities, but they’re often more tightly knit. Either way, you can find answers.

Operating system and interface

The Steam Deck runs SteamOS, a Linux-based operating system designed for the device. It’s not complicated, but it’s not a traditional game menu either. You’re navigating a system that has some overhead. The desktop mode is available if you want to tinker, which adds flexibility but also complexity.

Dedicated handhelds have simple menu systems — you select a game, it loads. No operating system to speak of. Just games. After a long day, sometimes that’s what you want. You don’t want to think.

Who Should Buy the Steam Deck for Retro Gaming?

The ideal candidate

You should buy the Steam Deck OLED if you:

  • Already use a PC for gaming and want to extend that ecosystem portably
  • Want to play a mix of retro and modern games on one device
  • Are willing to spend 20–30 minutes setting up emulators properly
  • Value versatility over simplicity
  • Have access to a power bank or regular charging opportunities
  • Want PlayStation 2, GameCube, Wii, or 3DS games specifically
  • Are interested in ROM hacks, fan translations, and experimental content
  • Have a desk or backpack, not a jacket pocket

You should buy a dedicated handheld like the Miyoo Mini Plus if you:

  • Only want classic systems (NES through PlayStation 1)
  • Value battery life over power (8+ hours matters to you)
  • Want zero setup — unbox and play
  • Prefer portability to screen size
  • Have a limited budget
  • Don’t want to think about emulation configurations
  • Use the device on the go regularly

You should buy the Analogue Pocket if you:

  • Specifically want the best Game Boy experience possible
  • Value accuracy above all else
  • Want a beautiful hardware object you’ll cherish
  • Primarily play Game Boy, Game Boy Color, and Game Boy Advance
  • Have the budget and don’t mind the premium

The Honest Verdict: Context Is Everything

I own a Steam Deck. I use it regularly for Baldur’s Gate 3, Hades, and occasionally for testing obscure emulation scenarios. For retro gaming specifically, I use it maybe once a week. I also own a Miyoo Mini Plus, which I carry everywhere and use most days. I pick it up during the commute, during breaks, whilst waiting for appointments. The Mini is always in my pocket. The Deck stays at home.

If I had to recommend one device for retro gaming and only retro gaming, I wouldn’t recommend the Deck. I’d point someone toward a dedicated handheld. They’re cheaper, simpler, more portable, and they do exactly one thing brilliantly. Recommending the Deck for retro gaming alone is like recommending a Ferrari for city commuting. It’ll work, it’ll be excellent, but you’re paying for capabilities you’re not using.

Where the Deck becomes the right choice is when you acknowledge what it actually is: a portable PC. It plays retro games, yes, but it also plays modern games. It runs desktop applications. It’s a device that expands what you can do, not just a specialized box that does one thing perfectly. If that versatility matters to you — if you want to play Chrono Trigger on your commute and Cyberpunk 2077 when you get home, all on one device — then the Deck’s price premium becomes justified.

The Steam Deck is worth it for retro gaming if you’re the kind of person who appreciates flexibility over simplicity. It’s worth it if you want access to more systems and more possibilities than any dedicated handheld offers. It’s worth it if you’re already in the PC gaming ecosystem and want to extend that into your pocket. But it’s not worth it just for retro gaming. If that’s your only interest, the Miyoo Mini Plus or an Anbernic device will serve you better, save you £450, and actually get used more often.

That’s not a criticism of the Deck. It’s a device doing exactly what it’s designed to do. But what it’s designed to do isn’t “perfect retro gaming handheld.” It’s “handheld gaming PC that happens to be excellent at emulation.” That’s a different question entirely.